
A supplier sends you a quote, photos of a clean production line and a stack of certificates. The price is right. Before you place a large order, you want to know one thing: does this factory exist, and can it make your product the way you need it, on time, without breaking the law?
Paperwork answers part of that. A factory audit or site visit answers the rest: someone stands on the floor, counts the machines, reads the quality records and talks to the workers.
This guide covers when an audit is worth paying for, which type to choose, how to run a remote check before anyone travels, what to look at on site, how to test certificates, and how to read the report. It assumes you have already confirmed the company is real and screened it. If not, start with our guides on how to verify an overseas supplier before you pay a deposit and how to screen a supplier against sanctions lists.
Audit, inspection and visit: three different checks
- A factory audit checks the supplier itself: its legal status, equipment, capacity, quality system and, in some audits, working conditions. You usually do it before the first order, then repeat it on a schedule.
- A product inspection checks the goods. A pre-shipment inspection pulls a random sample of finished products and compares it to your specification before the balance is paid. It tells you about one batch, not about the factory.
- A site visit is any trip to the factory, by you, your agent or a hired auditor. A visit becomes an audit when someone uses a written checklist, collects evidence and writes findings.
You need both an audit and an inspection for most new suppliers. The audit tells you whether to trust the factory with an order. The inspection tells you whether the order came out right.
When a factory audit is worth the cost
Match the depth of the check to what you stand to lose.
- Small trial order, standard product. Suggested check: Desk review plus live video walk-through. Why: Low loss if it goes wrong; a paid sample tells you most of what you need.
- First large order or a large deposit. Suggested check: Third-party on-site audit before the order. Why: Capacity and quality claims are hardest to test from a distance.
- Custom tooling or moulds you will pay for. Suggested check: On-site audit and a written tooling agreement. Why: You are paying for assets that sit in their building.
- Products sold to major retailers. Suggested check: Social compliance audit to the scheme your customer names. Why: Retailers often require a specific audit type.
- Goods with forced labour risk in the supply chain. Suggested check: Social audit plus supply chain mapping and records. Why: Customs rules in some markets put the burden of proof on the importer.
- Repeat supplier with a clean record. Suggested check: Re-audit every one to two years, or after a problem. Why: Factories change owners, staff and subcontractors.
A useful rule: if the deposit or tooling cost is larger than the price of an audit several times over, get the audit. Fees vary by firm, country, product and number of days, so ask two or three firms for written quotes.
The five types of factory audit
1. Supplier verification audit
The basic check: is the company registered, does it own or lease the site, is it a manufacturer or a trading company, how many workers and machines does it have, and what does it make? Some firms call it an initial or "simple" factory audit. For a first order with a new supplier, this is the minimum.
2. Technical and quality system audit
This audit asks whether the factory can make your product to spec, again and again. The auditor reviews incoming material checks, in-process checks, final inspection, calibration records, how defective goods are handled and whether batches can be traced back to their materials. Many checklists use ISO 9001 as the frame. ISO published a new edition, ISO 9001:2026, on 16 September 2026, according to ISO's quality management committee. Certificates to the 2015 edition stay usable during the transition, which ends on 30 September 2029, so for now you will see both.
3. Social compliance audit
This checks working hours, wages, health and safety, child labour, forced labour and how workers can raise complaints. Buyers usually ask for one of a few recognised schemes:
- SMETA, run through Sedex, is an audit method, not a certificate. The factory shares its report through the Sedex platform.
- SA8000 from Social Accountability International is a certification. You can check whether a site holds it in the SAAS certified facilities list.
- amfori BSCI is common with European retailers.
- The Responsible Business Alliance runs onsite assessments used widely in electronics.
- The Social & Labor Convergence Program offers a shared assessment used in apparel and footwear.
If your customer names a scheme, use that one. A different audit, however good, may not count.
4. Security audit
Some buyers need proof that cargo is protected from tampering between the factory and the port. In the United States, the CTPAT programme from Customs and Border Protection (CBP) sets minimum security criteria, and member importers are expected to check that their foreign suppliers meet them.
5. Environmental audit
This checks waste, water, chemicals and permits. It matters most in chemicals, dyeing, tanning and metal finishing.
Step 1: Do the desk review first
Most bad suppliers fail before anyone travels. Before you book an audit, collect and check:
- The business licence and registration number, checked in the official register for that country. In Vietnam, for example, that is the National Business Registration Portal. Our KYB checklist covers registers and ownership in more detail.
- Whether the registered address matches the factory address on the quote. A different address can be fine (many companies register an office in the city), but you want to know which building you are auditing.
- The business scope. A manufacturer's licence usually covers production. A trading company's usually covers sale and import or export.
- Export records, where they exist. Our guide on how to check a company's trade history shows how to read shipment data.
- References from other buyers, checked properly. See trade references and how verification works.
- Copies of every certificate the supplier claims, with certificate numbers. You will test these in Step 4.
Write down every claim the supplier makes (workers, machines, monthly output, main customers, years in business). The audit tests those claims.
Step 2: Run a live video walk-through
A live video call costs nothing and filters out many fakes. The rules that make it useful:
- Make it live and unscripted. A pre-recorded tour can come from any factory. Ask for the call at short notice.
- Start outside. Ask them to show the gate, the sign with the company name and the street. Compare it with the registered address on a map.
- Walk the full route. Raw material storage, production line, quality check station, finished goods, loading area. Ask them to keep the camera moving between areas so you can see the rooms connect.
- Ask for your product. Ask to see a line making something close to your item, and the machines named in the quote.
- Ask for records on camera. A recent incoming inspection sheet, a calibration label on a gauge, a defect log. A factory that controls quality keeps records.
- Check the date. Ask them to show a dated document on camera.
A video call says little about working conditions, and a trading company can borrow a friend's factory for an hour. Treat a good call as a pass to the next stage, not as an audit.
Step 3: Plan the on-site audit
For larger orders, send someone. That can be you, a sourcing agent or a third-party audit firm. Each has trade-offs.
- You or your staff. Strengths: You know the product; you build the relationship. Weaknesses: Travel cost; limited audit skills; language barrier.
- Sourcing agent. Strengths: Local language; often cheap. Weaknesses: May be paid by the factory too; ask how they are paid.
- Third-party audit firm. Strengths: Trained auditors; standard checklist; written report. Weaknesses: You must define the scope; quality varies by auditor.
Whoever goes, a few rules protect the result:
- You hire and pay the auditor. If the supplier picks or pays the auditor, the report is worth less.
- Agree the scope in writing. List which areas, which records and which of your products. A generic checklist may miss the one process that matters for your item.
- Decide on notice. Announced audits are easier to arrange and the right staff are present. Semi-announced or unannounced audits give a truer picture of normal days, which matters most for social audits. Many firms offer a window, such as "within the next two weeks", as a middle ground.
- Ask for photos with dates and locations. Photos of the gate, the sign, the machines and the records make the report checkable.
Step 4: Test the certificates
Certificates are easy to forge or borrow from a sister company. Check each one:
1. Read the name and address. The certificate should name the legal entity you are buying from and the site you are auditing. A certificate for a different company in the same group does not cover your factory.
2. Check the scope. An ISO 9001 certificate for "trading of electrical goods" says nothing about manufacturing them.
3. Check the dates. Look at the expiry date and when the last surveillance audit took place.
4. Check the certification body. Is it accredited by a recognised national accreditation body? Accredited certificates can often be checked in IAF CertSearch, a database run by the International Accreditation Forum. Not every certification body shares its data there, so a missing entry is a reason to ask, not proof of fraud.
5. Contact the issuer. Email the certification body named on the certificate and ask it to confirm the number, the company and the status. Use contact details from the body's own website, not from the certificate.
Do the same for product test reports. Ask the testing lab directly whether the report number exists and matches the product.
Step 5: What to check on the factory floor
A good audit compares what the factory says with what the auditor can see.
- Legal identity. Good evidence: Sign, licence and invoice all show the same company. Red flag: Different names on the gate, the contract and the bank account.
- Site control. Good evidence: Lease or ownership papers; the factory uses the whole site. Red flag: The company rents one floor of someone else's plant.
- Capacity. Good evidence: Machines listed in the quote are on site and running; staff on shift. Red flag: Quiet floor on a working day; machines covered in dust.
- Current workload. Good evidence: A production schedule that shows where your order fits. Red flag: "Any quantity, any date" before they ask what you need.
- Materials. Good evidence: Named material suppliers; incoming check records. Red flag: No idea where materials come from.
- Subcontracting. Good evidence: A written list of outsourced steps and who does them. Red flag: Key steps done elsewhere and not disclosed.
- Quality control. Good evidence: Check sheets at each stage, calibrated gauges, defect log. Red flag: Checks only at the end, no records.
- Defective goods. Good evidence: Separate area, clear labels, written rework process. Red flag: Rejects mixed with good stock.
- Workers. Good evidence: Payroll and time records that match what workers say. Red flag: Records that look too perfect; workers coached to answer.
- Safety. Good evidence: Clear fire exits, extinguishers in date, protective gear in use. Red flag: Locked exits, missing guards on machines.
On subcontracting, ask which steps happen in other factories, and audit those too if they matter to quality or compliance. Hidden subcontracting is a common cause of both quality failures and social compliance problems.
Step 6: Watch for forced labour risk
Forced labour is now a customs issue as well as an ethical one.
In the United States, CBP enforces a rebuttable presumption under the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act. Goods made wholly or partly in Xinjiang, or by an entity on the UFLPA Entity List, are presumed banned from import unless the importer proves otherwise. A clean audit of your direct supplier will not answer that on its own. You also need records that trace key materials, such as cotton, polysilicon or aluminium, back up the supply chain.
In the European Union, the Forced Labour Regulation bans products made with forced labour from the EU market, and from export out of it, from 14 December 2027. The Commission notes that the regulation does not itself require audits or reports. In practice, buyers will still need evidence if a product is questioned. Germany's Supply Chain Act and the UK's transparency in supply chains guidance set further duties for larger companies.
The International Labour Organization's indicators of forced labour give auditors a practical list. Examples include withheld identity papers, withheld wages, debt bondage through recruitment fees, restricted movement and excessive overtime. Ask your auditor to cover them, including private interviews with workers away from managers.
Step 7: Read the report and decide
A good report gives findings with evidence, not just a score. When you read it:
- Check that the auditor saw what you asked. Compare the report to the scope you agreed. Missing sections need an explanation.
- Look at the photos. Do they show the same gate, sign and machines as the video call? Do the dates match the audit day?
- Separate major from minor findings. A missing fire drill record is minor. Locked exits, child workers, fake records or undisclosed subcontracting are major.
- Compare claims with findings. If the supplier said 300 workers and the auditor counted 80, that gap matters more than the score.
- Ask for a corrective action plan. For fixable findings, agree what will change, who is responsible and by when. Then verify it, by photos for small items or a follow-up audit for serious ones.
Then approve, approve with conditions, or reject, and write down the date and reason. Conditions might include a smaller first order, a pre-shipment inspection on every shipment, or a follow-up audit within six months.
A short worked example
This example is made up. A homeware importer in Canada wants 20,000 ceramic mugs from a new supplier. The quote asks for a 30% deposit and a fee for custom moulds.
The desk review checks out: the licence is live and the scope covers ceramic production. The video call shows kilns, a glazing line and a sign with the right name. The importer then books a third-party supplier verification audit with a quality section.
The auditor finds two problems. The factory is real, but glazing for decorated items is sent to a second workshop that was never mentioned. And the ISO 9001 certificate belongs to a sister company at a different address.
The importer adds the second workshop to the audit scope and treats the certificate as missing. The first order is cut to 5,000 mugs with a pre-shipment inspection, and the mould agreement states in writing that the importer owns the moulds. After two clean shipments, the importer raises the order size.
Common mistakes
- Treating a certificate as an audit. A certificate says a system was checked at some point. It does not say your order will be made well.
- Auditing the showroom, not the plant. Audit the building where your goods will be made.
- One audit and done. Ownership, staff and subcontractors change. Re-audit on a schedule.
- Skipping the inspection because the audit passed. A good factory can still ship a bad batch.
- No link to payment terms. Use the audit result to set terms. The US International Trade Administration's guide to methods of payment explains how options like letters of credit shift risk between buyer and seller.
How TradeRepute fits
A factory audit tells you what a site looked like on one day. It does not tell you how the supplier behaved with other buyers over months: whether it delivered on time, handled defects fairly or changed bank details mid-order. That is where trade references help.
TradeRepute collects references from verified reviewers about how a company has traded. It is not a credit bureau, and references are opinions, not guarantees. Evidence is reviewed, but accuracy is not guaranteed. Read references next to your own register checks, sanctions screening, audit report and inspection results. Our review standards explain how references are checked, and our guide to vetting an overseas supplier and the counterparty due diligence checklist show where an audit sits in a full supplier file.
Disclaimer
Business-to-business trade references for due-diligence purposes only. Not a credit report, credit rating or legal, financial or investment advice. References are the opinions of verified reviewers. Reviewers are anonymous to the public and the reviewed company. Evidence is reviewed but accuracy is not guaranteed; companies may dispute a reference privately.
- Supplier verification
- Factory audits
- Due diligence
- Sourcing
- Forced labour


